| Name | Title | Date Appointed |
| William T. Ryburn | Postmaster | 05/27/1837 |
| Samuel T. Russell | Postmaster | 05/16/1842 |
| Byrd T. Ryburn | Postmaster | 11/11/1842 |
| Samuel T. Russell | Postmaster | 04/05/1847 |
| Abraham B. Cornman | Postmaster | 07/14/1849 |
| Hugh M. Richart | Postmaster | 12/05/1850 |
| John B. Russell | Postmaster | 04/27/1861 |
| Gilbert Davis | Postmaster | 02/22/1864 |
| Samuel H. Bundy | Postmaster | 07/22/1865 |
| Francis M. Sparks | Postmaster | 01/29/1867 |
| William D. Chamberlain | Postmaster | 04/19/1869 |
| George W. Sisney | Postmaster | 08/31/1869 |
| George W. McNeal | Postmaster | 12/18/1871 |
| Jonathan A. Bandy | Postmaster | 06/24/1872 |
| Benjamin F. Tranbarger | Postmaster | 11/07/1872 |
| C. M. Scott | Postmaster | 01/30/1874 |
| John D. Herrin | Postmaster | 02/08/1875 |
| Christopher C. Bradley* | Postmaster | 07/27/1876 |
| Richard H. H. Hampton | Postmaster | 11/09/1876 |
| Albert K. Elles | Postmaster | 10/14/1878 |
| George W. Duncan | Postmaster | 11/16/1881 |
| George L. Owen | Postmaster | 09/19/1882 |
| William H. Perry | Postmaster | 02/08/1883 |
| Mrs. Ella N. Sprague | Postmaster | 07/28/1885 |
| Mrs. Ella N. Winning** | Postmaster | 07/09/1886 |
| Maggie Thompson | Postmaster | 03/26/1888 |
| David P. McFadin | Postmaster | 04/28/1893 |
| Herbert W. Cann | Postmaster | 04/25/1894 |
| James A. Lauder | Postmaster | 07/19/1898 |
| Luther E. Robertson | Postmaster | 03/24/1914 |
| Lucy E. Robertson | Acting Postmaster | 07/03/1914 |
| Benjamin L. Washburn | Postmaster | 02/03/1915 |
| Cecil W. Bishop | Postmaster | 04/14/1923 |
| Cecil W. Bishop | Postmaster | 01/07/1924 |
| Roger M. Tippy | Acting Postmaster | 10/09/1933 |
| Roger M. Tippy | Postmaster | 03/18/1935 |
| Mrs. Gertrude Tippy | Acting Postmaster | 08/13/1943 |
| Mrs. Gertrude Tippy | Postmaster | 08/24/1944 |
| Fred J. Rudloff | Acting Postmaster | 07/25/1949 |
| Fred J. Rudloff | Postmaster | 09/12/1950 |
| Walter B. Tregoning | Acting Postmaster | 03/15/1955 |
| Walter B. Tregoning | Postmaster | 05/22/1958 |
| Frank J. Hampton | Officer-In-Charge | 04/30/1971 |
| Raymond D. Rogers | Postmaster | 03/18/1972 |
| Donald P. Evans | Officer-In-Charge | 07/24/1981 |
| Kenneth Drew | Postmaster | 12/26/1981 |
| Vincent L. Fisher | Officer-In-Charge | 09/30/1992 |
| Robert D. Maurizio | Officer-In-Charge | 02/05/1993 |
| Robert D. Maurizio | Postmaster | 02/20/1993 |
Discontinued October 21, 1847
Reestablished July 14, 1849
Discontinued April 29, 1865
Reestablished July 22, 1865
Changed to CARTERVILLE December 18, 1871
*Christopher C. Bradley - May not have served.
**Mrs. Ella N. Winning - Name probably changed from Mrs. Ella
N. Sprague